01 Jun 2026
By Louis Francis, Solicitor, Corporate, Gilson Gray
As anticipation builds for the FIFA World Cup 2026, discussions have already begun around the potential disputes and disciplinary challenges that could emerge during the tournament. With an expanded format featuring 48 teams, the scale and intensity of the competition are expected to increase significantly, bringing a heightened risk of on-field and off-field controversies.
Player Discipline and On-Field Conduct
One of the most prominent areas of concern is player discipline. In recent World Cup tournaments, there has been a noticeable rise in yellow and red cards, often stemming from tactical fouls and dissent toward referees.
FIFA have looked to combat concerns in discipline by introducing major rule changes such as:
(i) stamping down on time wasting (by introducing a five-second countdown on throw-ins and goal kicks);
(ii) introducing a time limit for a player to leave / enter the pitch when making a substitution; and
(iii) introducing a new rule where players can receive a red card for leaving the pitch to protest a referee’s decision or covering their mouths when confronting an opposition player on the pitch.
Refereeing Pressure and Consistency
Referees are under more pressure than ever to ensure they maintain consistency in decision-making. Ensuring uniform enforcement of rules will be essential to avoid accusations of bias or inconsistency, which have historically fuelled disputes among players, coaches, and fans.
VAR and Technological Decision-Making
Video Assistant Referee (VAR) technology, while designed to reduce errors, remains a common source of contention. Although it will be strongly argued by the governing bodies that it has improved decision accuracy, VAR has also introduced delays and disagreements over subjective calls, such as handballs or fouls in the penalty area. Teams that feel disadvantaged by VAR decisions often publicly question its fairness, which can escalate tensions both on and off the pitch. At the 2026 tournament, the introduction and use of upgraded officiating technology could either alleviate or intensify disputes, depending on how the technology is interpreted by the officials and how transparently and efficiently it is implemented and shared with the fans.
Scheduling, Travel, and Player Welfare
Another potential area of dispute involves scheduling and travel logistics. With matches spread across three large countries and multiple time zones, teams could face uneven travel burdens, potentially affecting performance and recovery time. Complaints about scheduling fairness (such as unequal rest periods between matches) may lead to formal protests or public criticism from national football associations. National associations and players will be working closely with their sports scientists in order to minimise injury risk and maximise recovery.
Off-Field Discipline and Conduct Regulations
Off-field discipline is also expected to be closely monitored. FIFA has taken a stronger stance in recent years on issues such as discrimination, political statements, and player (and fan) conduct on social media. At a global event like the World Cup, where players are under intense scrutiny, any breach of conduct regulations could lead to fines, suspensions, or further disciplinary action. Managing these issues will be particularly challenging given the diverse cultural and political contexts represented by participating nations. Players may find themselves on the receiving end of a footballing ban in the middle of a tournament, which will no doubt lead to appeals and disputes between the national associations and governing bodies.
Governance, Eligibility, and Regulatory Disputes
It is almost inevitable that a dispute between governing bodies, national associations, teams and players will arise over regulations, eligibility rules, or officiating decisions. The expanded tournament format itself has already sparked debate regarding competitive balance and player welfare, with critics arguing that increased match loads could heighten injury risks and fatigue.
Conclusion
While the 2026 World Cup promises to be a landmark sporting event, it will face a range of disputes and disciplinary challenges. Addressing these issues proactively through clear communication, consistent rule enforcement, and effective use of technology will be crucial to preserving the integrity and spirit of the game.
View our full Sports service offering here.
